Understanding Comedogenicity in Skincare: What You Really Need to Know
When it comes to skincare, one truth is clear: nobody wants products filled with pore-clogging ingredients—especially if you’re struggling with acne or irritated skin.
With growing ingredient awareness, the topic of comedogenicity can feel confusing and is full of misconceptions. We’ve heard so many great questions about how to spot truly non-comedogenic formulas. So today, we’re sharing practical tips to help you choose skincare that keeps your pores clear and your skin happy.
Together we'll dive into:
-
A balanced understanding of non-comedogenic and pore-clogging ingredients
-
Answers to your most-asked questions
-
Our perspective on skincare formulation
-
A clearer look at commonly misunderstood “comedogenic” ingredients
Comedogenicity Defined
When choosing skincare products—especially those with rich, plant-based ingredients—one word often comes up: comedogenicity. But what does it actually mean? And should you avoid all “comedogenic” ingredients?
Let’s take a closer look, with the nuance and clarity this topic deserves.
Comedogenicity refers to the likelihood of a substance to clog pores, potentially leading to the formation of comedones—skin blemishes like blackheads and whiteheads. This concept is especially relevant for those with acne-prone or congested skin.
How Is Comedogenicity Measured?
Historically, comedogenicity was measured using rabbit ears (yes, really), assigning ingredients a rating from 0 to 5:
-
0 = Non-comedogenic (won’t clog pores)
-
1–2 = Low
-
3 = Moderate
-
4–5 = High (more likely to clog pores)
But here’s the catch: rabbit ears aren’t human skin. These tests frequently used high concentrations of ingredients—much higher than what you’d actually find in skincare. And they didn’t account for how ingredients behave within a complete formula. It’s no surprise, then, that confusion about comedogenicity still circulates today.
The Truth About “Pore-Clogging” Natural Ingredients
In the natural beauty space, deeply nourishing ingredients like coconut oil, shea butter, or marula oil are sometimes labeled as “highly comedogenic.” But that doesn’t mean they’re inherently bad—or even that they’ll clog your pores.
Here’s why:
-
Comedogenicity is dose-dependent
Used in low percentages or thoughtfully paired with non-comedogenic oils, even a “comedogenic” ingredient can play a beneficial role. In our Everything + Blue Tansy Balm, for example, marula oil is used at less than 10% alongside organic tallow, jojoba, and squalane—creating a deeply nourishing but balanced formula. -
Your skin type matters
What clogs oily or acne-prone skin may be perfectly fine (even beneficial) for dry, dehydrated, or mature skin. Unlike mass-market products aiming to appeal to everyone, we tailor our formulations with specific needs in mind. -
Ingredient synergy matters
How one ingredient interacts with others influences texture, absorption, and overall performance. A so-called “comedogenic” oil in the right blend can deliver amazing results without the risk.
Our Approach to Comedogenicity
At Edenwild, we celebrate the power of nature—not by using every botanical we can find, but by choosing what serves your skin best. Rather than avoiding all potentially comedogenic ingredients, we:
-
Formulate mindfully
Using low to moderate concentrations that support the skin barrier -
Prioritize skin type compatibility
Our facial care collection includes specific recommendations designed for oily, combination, dry, and sensitive skin types -
Focus on whole-plant synergy
Every ingredient is handpicked to complement one another and create harmony with your skin
For example, our beloved anti-aging serum Dewdrop features jojoba oil (non-comedogenic) as the base, perfectly blended with pomegranate seed oil and squalane for a light, regenerative feel—proof that thoughtful formulation matters.
Final Thoughts
Comedogenicity is a helpful guide—but it’s not a rulebook. What matters most is how a product is formulated, how it works with your skin type, and whether it supports your long-term skincare goals.
When in doubt:
-
Patch test new products
-
Listen to what your skin is telling you
-
Choose brands that care deeply about both the science and the soul of skincare
At Edenwild, that’s our promise. Skincare that nourishes, supports wellness, and brings harmony to your skin—not heaviness. Because caring for your skin should be simple, honest, and beautifully intentional.
Down to earth skincare — for our family, and yours.